Published · · Last reviewed · · 6 min read

English · 한국어

Now versus later: present bias and the lump-sum choice

"Would you rather have KRW 1,000,000 now or KRW 1,100,000 in a year?" Many people answer "now". Ask "KRW 1,000,000 in five years or KRW 1,100,000 in six?" and the same people often pick six years. Both are the same deal, "wait one more year and get 100,000 more", yet the answer flips. This is called present bias, and it can appear at the moment when you decide whether to take a lottery prize as a lump sum or as an annuity. All numbers on this page are assumptions for explanation and predict no one's choice.

With constant discounting nothing flips

In a rational calculation value is cut by the same proportion for each year of waiting (exponential discounting). Someone who discounts at 10% a year treats KRW 1,000,000 now and KRW 1,100,000 in a year as equal. KRW 1,000,000 in five years and KRW 1,100,000 in six are also equal, since both are worth KRW 621,000 today. With the same proportional cut each year, the two deals move in step and a preference never flips.

Assumption: valuation by someone who discounts a constant 10% a year (present value, KRW 10,000)
OptionValue today
KRW 1,000,000 now100.0
KRW 1,100,000 in 1 year100.0
KRW 1,000,000 in 5 years62.1
KRW 1,100,000 in 6 years62.1

Someone who cuts steeply only for the near future

Present bias is a valuation with a big step between "now" and "not now". The standard formula is quasi-hyperbolic discounting (the β-δ model): what you get now is valued as it is, while every future payment is multiplied once more by β (less than 1) and then discounted by δ per year. Laibson (1997) analysed how hyperbolic discount functions lead to preferences that are inconsistent over time, which gives people a motive to constrain their own future choices (abstract checked). β = 0.7 and δ = 0.95 are values assumed here for illustration.

Assumption: valuation by someone with β = 0.7, δ = 0.95 (value today, KRW 10,000)
OptionCalculationValue today
KRW 1,000,000 nowas is100.0
KRW 1,100,000 in 1 year110 × 0.7 × 0.9573.2
KRW 1,000,000 in 5 years100 × 0.7 × 0.95⁵54.2
KRW 1,100,000 in 6 years110 × 0.7 × 0.95⁶56.6

This person chooses now in "100 against 73.2 for a year" and chooses to wait in "54.2 against 56.6 for 5 against 6 years". The same deal pushed later in time flips the choice. Five years on, asked the same question from that new "now", the person would pick the immediate option again and break the plan made five years earlier (wait for year six). That is time inconsistency. Thaler (1981) is often cited as reporting this phenomenon; this page checked only the bibliographic record and summaries of that paper and quotes none of its figures.

What does waiting have to pay?

The signature of present bias is that "how much extra is needed to wait a year" depends on when the year falls. The β = 0.7, δ = 0.95 person above, to wait a year instead of taking KRW 1,000,000 now, needs 100 ÷ (0.7 × 0.95) = KRW 1,504,000, that is 50.4% more. To move from year 5 to year 6 only 100 ÷ 0.95 = KRW 1,053,000 is needed, 5.3% more. A constant discounter at 10% a year asks for 10% at any time.

Extra amount demanded for waiting one more year (assumed values)
PersonNow → in 1 yearYear 5 → year 6
Constant discounter at 10% a year+10.0%+10.0%
Person with β = 0.7, δ = 0.95+50.4%+5.3%

It is the same "one year" but the near year is priced high and the far year low. That difference is what flips the choice. Making plans for the distant future, "I can do it later" is easy, but when that "later" becomes "now" the same plan suddenly looks expensive. This shape is often used to explain why savings and exercise plans get postponed. What this page offers is the arithmetic of a model, not a claim about how many people behave this way or by how much.

Questions to ask about your own choice

Even outside the lottery these questions help to notice present bias. If I fixed this choice for a year from now, would I give the same answer? Do I need the immediate option because it is truly "now", or does it attract me only because it is now? What is the price of waiting if I write it as a number? Writing it down shows things. If you take a lump sum that implies 4.28% a year and doubt you can invest it at more than 4.28%, the annuity may be better; if you have an urgent use for money today, the lump sum may be. That judgement depends on circumstances and this page does not make it for you.

Lottery lump sums and annuities

For big lottery prizes the winner sometimes chooses between a lump sum (cash) and payments over many years (Lump sum vs annuity calculator), and present bias tilts that choice towards the lump sum. The numbers below are an assumption for illustration. Compare an annuity whose payments total 100 (arbitrary unit) in 30 payments, each year 5% larger than the last and the first paid at once, against a lump sum of 50 now.

Assumption: present value of an annuity of total 100, 30 payments, growing 5% a year, first payment at once
Discount rate (per year)Present value of the annuityCompared with a lump sum of 50
0%100.0annuity better
3%60.5annuity better
4.28%50.0equal (the rate implied by a lump sum of 50)
5%45.2lump sum better
10%24.9lump sum better

A lump sum of 50 means the annuity is better for someone whose discount rate is below 4.28% a year and the lump sum is better for someone above it. Now take a person who discounts at 3% (δ = 1/1.03) and who multiplies future payments by β = 0.7 as well. The first payment arrives at once and stays as it is, while the other 29 are multiplied by 0.7, so the value of the annuity falls from 60.5 to 42.8. The annuity (42.8) is now below the lump sum of 50 and the choice flips to the lump sum. Someone with the same patience (3% a year) can reach a different conclusion because of present bias alone. This page cannot judge which is right: a lump-sum chooser may want to spend earlier, may have an investment opportunity, or may simply be present-biased.

The first prize of Korea's Pension Lottery 720+ pays KRW 7 million a month for 20 years, a nominal total of KRW 1.68 billion. Discounted at 3% it is worth KRW 1.26 billion, at 5% KRW 1.06 billion, at 10% KRW 0.73 billion and at 20% KRW 0.41 billion (monthly payments, first one a month from now). The same prize is worth anything from KRW 0.4 billion to KRW 1.7 billion today depending on the rate used. I could not confirm whether this lottery offers a lump-sum option.

Change the numbers

In the tool below you can vary the discount rate and the payment structure and compare the present values of a lump sum and an annuity.

This tool needs JavaScript.

Using the idea

Knowing about present bias does not remove it. That is why the remedy studied is to bind your future choice in advance. When a large sum arrives, set a rule for choosing between lump sum and annuity before the money comes, and when deciding write down the discount rate you actually use instead of going by how you feel now. Computing the rate implied by a lump sum (4.28% in the table above) lets you compare in a sentence: "this lump sum pays off only if I can earn more than 4.28% a year". This page recommends neither option; tax and personal circumstances have to be weighed separately.

What the model leaves out

The β-δ model is one of the simplest ways to describe present bias, and studies differ on how well real discounting follows it. The β, δ, KRW 1,000,000 and total of 100 here are all assumptions for explanation, not values for any real person or lottery product. Laibson's paper was checked through the public abstract summary and Thaler's through its bibliographic record and summaries; I could not open the full texts. The pension lottery figures follow from the assumptions of KRW 7 million a month, 240 payments and a first payment one month away.

Sources and verification